![]() | ![]() |
Leases and Insolvency29 Apr 2013 In this article we seek to highlight:
The type of insolvency appointment will determine when the Insolvency Practitioner’s obligation arises to pay rent and the landlords ability to enter into possession of the property. 1. Obligations to Pay Rent • Receiver/Controller The Act makes a Receiver (or Controller) liable for rent payable by a Corporate tenant seven (7) days after the control day1 . A Controller may give the owner or lessor a notice under Section 419A(3) of the Act that states that he/she does not intend to exercise rights in relation to the property. If the Notice is not sent, the Controller is liable until: i) the Controller retires; or • Voluntary Administration An Administrator is personally liable for debts incurred in the course of the Administration in respect of property hired or leased, used or occupied. An Administrator is only liable for amounts payable under the lease: i) for the period beginning five (5) business days after the Administration began; and where Within five (5) business days after the administration began, the Administrator may give the owner or lessor a notice under Section 443B(3) of the Act that states that the company does not propose to exercise rights in relation to the property. If the notice is not issued within five (5) business days of the administration commencing and the company continues to occupy the property, the Administrator becomes liable for ongoing rent and other monies owed under the lease. • Liquidation A Liquidator is not personally liable for rent during the liquidation (including any rental arrears). However, if the Liquidator decides that the Company will continue to occupy the premises, the rent for the period of occupation will be a cost of the winding up. 2. Rights of the Landlord to Possession • Receivership A Receiver is not provided with any protection under the Act (compare this to a Voluntary Administrator – refer below), which would limit the rights of the landlord. Consequently, a landlord may commence proceedings to gain possession or force compliance with the terms of the lease, notwithstanding the appointment of a Receiver. • Voluntary Administration During the Administration of a company the owner or lessor of property that is used or occupied by, or was in possession of the company cannot take possession of the property or otherwise recover it except: i) with the Administrator’s written consent, or This does not apply where the lease has already ended when the Administration commenced and the landlord has entered into possession. Notwithstanding the appointment of an Administrator, the landlord can still issue a Default Notice and Notice of Termination (where the tenant has failed to comply with the terms of the lease), the landlord will then be able to resume possession when the Voluntary Administration ends. The landlord may make an application to Court under Section 440B of the Act to take possession of the property. In deciding whether to grant the landlord leave to recover the property prior to the conclusion of the Voluntary Administration, in a recent court case it was held that2 : i) The landlord bears the onus of proof of persuading the Court that leave should be granted; • Liquidation Normally, commercial leases are drafted so that an insolvency event is a default by a tenant under the lease. This would normally give the landlord the immediate right to terminate the lease in an insolvency event (except when a Voluntary Administrator has been appointed). On appointment, a Liquidator will either seek to: i) Disclaim the lease. That is, the Liquidator may take the view that the lease is an onerous contract; or ii) If he/she requires the premises, a Liquidator should generally notify the landlord that continued occupation is necessary, however the Liquidator is unlikely to adopt the lease. He/she will only be liable for rent for the period they occupy the premises. Where the Liquidator has not disclaimed the lease, a landlord may give a notice to a Liquidator requiring the Liquidator to nominate whether or not the Liquidator intends to disclaim the lease. The Liquidator must respond within 28 days. The purpose of this notice is to enable the landlord to determine as quickly as reasonably practicable what is going to happen to its lease. SMITH HANCOCK’S COMMENTS The main focus of a landlord when faced with a tenant that is subject to an insolvency event is to mitigate the potential for lost rental and/or gain control of the property. Key points to note: The landlord’s rights on a tenant’s insolvency to either terminate and/or enter into possession can be subject to: i) Lease conditions; To mitigate loss following the appointment of an insolvency practitioner the landlord should: • Ascertain the practitioner’s intentions regarding continued occupation (both short and long term); • Call on the bank guarantee/security deposit, subject to the lease conditions; • The landlord should also attend meetings of creditors convened.
If you or your client is faced with the prospect of the failure of a tenant, please do not hesitate to discuss the issue with us to determine the best course of action in the circumstances. 1 Control day is the day when the Receiver or Receiver & Manager was appointed 2 Imo Colorado Group Limited [2011] VSC 552 Para 59 |
News & Updates![]() Alert to Advisors - Potential Personal Liability Read all
![]() Covid-19 Safe Harbour Protection for Directors Read all
![]() The Dangers of Lending to Loved Ones Read all
![]() Impending Changes to the DPN and PPSR Update Read all
![]() Recent criminal changes to the Director Penalty Notice Regime Read all
![]() Gaol Time for Delinquent Company Directors / PPSR Update Read all
![]() When is a Guarantee Not a Guarantee? Read all
![]() Illegal Phoenix Operations & Determining Right to Income Read all
![]() New & Proposed Legislative Changes Read all
![]() Voidable Property Transfer & Director Liability Read all
![]() Welcome to New Partner and Reforms to Insolvency Law Read all
![]() ASIC Statistics and Enforcement Read all
![]() Government Targets Foreign Investors with New Tax Legislation Read all
![]() Dodgy Advisers – Watch Out! Read all
![]() Steering the Ship onto Rocks: Directors Flouting Obligations Read all
![]() From the Mining Boom to the Ideas Boom - What it All Means Read all
![]() When is a Debt to the ATO Due and Payable Read all
![]() ATO and Phoenix Activity Read all
![]() Unreasonable Director-related Transactions & PPSA Update Read all
![]() PPS and ASIC Prosecution Read all
![]() Leases and Insolvency Read all
![]() PPS Update Read all
![]() Expansion of Director Liability Provisions (PAYG & SGC) Now Law Read all
![]() Proposed Changes to Corporations Act (Phoenix Activity) and Taxation Act (Director Penalty) Read all
![]() March 2012 PPSA Newsletter Practical Worked Examples Read all
![]() Personal Property Securities Act ("PPSA") Now Law Read all
![]() PPS Reform - Understanding Security Interests: Perfection and Priorities Read all
![]() Tax Changes - Expansion of Director Liability Provisions Read all
![]() Australian Taxation Office - Statutory Garnishee Notices Read all
![]() Major Change to Registering Security Interests – Personal Property Securities Reform Read all
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|